Table of Contents

What is Criminal Appeal and When Can You File It?

A criminal appeal lets you challenge your conviction or sentence in a higher court if you believe the trial court made a mistake. It's a legal remedy under CrPC (now BNSS) that gives hope to those wrongfully convicted or unfairly sentenced.

At Metis Law Chamber, we have successfully handled many criminal convictions in Punjab & Haryana High Court and the Supreme Court. We specialize in finding legal errors, procedural mistakes, and evidence problems that can reverse convictions or reduce sentences.

Types of Criminal Appeals:

  • Appeal against conviction : Challenge the guilty verdict itself
  • Appeal against sentence : Contest the punishment as too harsh
  • Appeal against acquittal : The prosecution challenges a not-guilty verdict (filed by the state, not you)
  • Revision petition : Ask a higher court to review lower court decisions
  • Special Leave Petition (SLP) : Direct appeal to the Supreme Court
  • Bail during appeal : Get released from jail while your appeal is pending

Not all convictions are final. We review trial records to identify grounds for appeal and fight to overturn wrongful convictions.

  └─ Purpose of Criminal Appeals in the Justice System

Criminal appeals ensure that convictions and sentences get reviewed by higher courts. The appeal process protects you from:

  • Legal mistakes made by the trial judge
  • Evidence being misunderstood or ignored
  • Procedural errors that made your trial unfair

What Appeals Do (and Don't Do):

Appeals don't retry your entire case with new witnesses and evidence. Instead, appellate courts review the trial record to check if:

  • The law was applied correctly
  • Legal procedures were followed properly
  • Your constitutional rights were protected

If the higher court finds serious errors, they can overturn your conviction or reduce your sentence.

  └─ Court’s Role in Criminal Appeal Proceedings

When reviewing your appeal, higher courts balance your rights with the needs of justice and public safety.

What Appellate Courts Check:

  • Did the trial court apply the law correctly?
  • Were proper legal procedures followed?
  • Is the conviction supported by actual evidence?

It is important to note that the appellate court doesn't start from scratch or assume you are innocent. Instead, they review the trial court's decision to see if it was legal, correct, and fair based on the evidence and law.

If they find serious errors, they can overturn the conviction or order a new trial.

  └─ Complete Criminal Appeal Process in High Court

1

Conviction Analysis & Grounds

Comprehensive review of trial court judgment, evidence, and proceedings to identify strong grounds for appeal and legal errors.

2

Appeal Preparation & Filing

Prepare detailed appeal petition with grounds, compile trial court records, and file within statutory limitation period.

3

Record Compilation & Service

Obtain complete trial court records, prepare appeal compilation, and serve notice to respondent parties.

4

Bail Pending Appeal

File application for suspension of sentence and bail pending appeal to secure interim relief during proceedings.

5

Written Submissions & Arguments

Prepare comprehensive written arguments, legal research, and present oral arguments before High Court bench.

6

Appeal Decision & Further Relief

Obtain favorable appeal judgment and pursue further legal remedies if required, including Supreme Court appeal.

  └─ Legal Grounds for Filing Criminal Appeals

Criminal appeals can be filed on various legal grounds when trial court has committed errors in law, fact, or procedure:

Errors of Law:

  • Misinterpretation of Law: Wrong application of legal provisions
  • Procedural Violations: Non-compliance with CrPC procedures
  • Constitutional Violations: Breach of fundamental rights
  • Jurisdictional Errors: Court lacking proper jurisdiction
  • Legal Precedent Ignored: Failure to follow binding precedents

Errors of Fact:

  • Evidence Misappreciation: Wrong evaluation of evidence
  • Witness Credibility: Improper assessment of witness testimony
  • Factual Findings: Conclusions not supported by evidence
  • Benefit of Doubt: Failure to give benefit of doubt to accused
  • Circumstantial Evidence: Incomplete chain of circumstances

Procedural Errors:

  • Charge Framing: Improper framing of charges
  • Evidence Recording: Violations in evidence recording
  • Right to Defense: Denial of fair trial rights
  • Prosecution Procedure: Procedural lapses by prosecution
  • Judicial Bias: Bias or prejudice by trial judge

Sentence Related Grounds:

  • Excessive Sentence: Punishment disproportionate to offense
  • Mitigating Factors: Court ignored mitigating circumstances
  • Sentencing Guidelines: Violation of sentencing principles
  • Alternative Punishment: Availability of lesser punishment

  └─ Common Mistakes to Avoid in Criminal Appeals

Avoiding common mistakes in criminal appeals can significantly improve chances of success:

Procedural Mistakes:

  • Missing Limitation Period: Filing appeal after 30-day deadline without condonation
  • Incomplete Documentation: Not filing complete trial court records and compilation
  • Wrong Court Selection: Filing in court without proper jurisdiction
  • Improper Service: Failure to serve notice to all respondent parties
  • Court Fee Errors: Paying incorrect court fees or fee calculation mistakes

Legal Strategy Mistakes:

  • Weak Grounds: Filing appeal without strong legal grounds
  • Factual Re-agitation: Trying to re-argue facts instead of focusing on legal errors
  • Precedent Ignorance: Not citing relevant case laws and precedents
  • Poor Legal Research: Inadequate research on applicable laws and judgments
  • Generic Arguments: Using template arguments instead of case-specific points

Client Behavior Mistakes:

  • Bail Condition Violations: Violating bail conditions during appeal pendency
  • Public Statements: Making media statements that can prejudice appeal
  • Witness Contact: Attempting to contact prosecution witnesses
  • Document Destruction: Destroying potential evidence during appeal

Our experienced appellate lawyers help clients avoid these common pitfalls and maximize appeal success prospects through strategic planning and meticulous preparation.

Why Choose Metis Law Chamber for Criminal Appeals?

High Convictions Overturned Rate

Proven track record of successfully challenging trial court convictions through expert appellate advocacy and comprehensive legal research.

Proven Success Rate in High Court

High success rate in criminal appeals through meticulous case preparation, legal research, and persuasive appellate arguments.

25+ Years Appellate Experience

Extensive experience in High Court and Supreme Court criminal appeals with deep understanding of appellate procedures and jurisprudence.

Specialized Appeal Research

Dedicated legal research team identifying grounds for appeal, precedent analysis, and comprehensive appellate brief preparation.

Supreme Court Practice

Experienced Supreme Court advocates for complex constitutional issues and high-profile criminal appeals requiring expert representation.

Client Testimonials for Criminal Appeal Matters

RK

Rajeev Khanna

Chandigarh

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"I consulted the firm for a criminal appeal after conviction. The lawyers explained the appellate procedure clearly and guided me responsibly through the legal process."

Appeal against Conviction
SM

Suresh Mehta

Mohali

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"The legal team provided clear advice regarding appeal grounds and limitation. Their structured approach helped me understand the appellate process better."

Appeal against Acquittal
AV

Anil Verma

Panchkula

⭐⭐⭐⭐

"I received professional guidance in filing a criminal appeal. The lawyers were transparent about the scope and limitations of appellate proceedings."

Appeal against Sentence
KA

Kamal Arora

Chandigarh

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"The appeal process was explained patiently, including bail pending appeal. I appreciated the responsible and procedural handling of the matter."

Appeal against Sentence
RB

Rohit Bansal

Mohali

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

"The lawyers demonstrated strong understanding of criminal appeal law and ensured that all legal steps were followed properly."

Appeal against Acquittal
DS

Deepak Sharma

Kullu

⭐⭐⭐⭐

"Clear legal advice and structured drafting of the appeal helped me navigate a complex post-conviction situation."

Revision Petition

Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Appeals

What is the time limit for filing criminal appeal?

Criminal appeals must be filed within 30 days of the judgment in High Court. For Supreme Court SLP, the limit is 90 days from High Court order. Delay can be condoned with sufficient cause.

Can I get bail while my appeal is pending?

Yes, you can apply for bail pending appeal under Section 389 CrPC. Success depends on strong appeal grounds, nature of offense, sentence duration, and other factors like flight risk.

Can I file appeal against acquittal?

Only the State government or complainant can file appeal against acquittal, not the accused. Private parties can approach State to file appeal or file revision petition in limited circumstances.

What happens if my appeal is rejected by High Court?

If High Court rejects your appeal, you can file Special Leave Petition (SLP) in Supreme Court within 90 days. Supreme Court is the final court of appeal in criminal matters.

Can I change my lawyer during appeal proceedings?

Yes, you can change lawyers during appeal proceedings by filing appropriate applications. However, this may cause delays and additional costs, so choose experienced appellate lawyers initially.

Is it necessary to engage the same lawyer who fought trial?

No, it's not necessary to engage the same trial lawyer for appeals. In fact, specialized appellate lawyers often provide better representation as appeal skills differ from trial advocacy.

Wrongfully Convicted? Challenge Your Conviction with Expert Appeal Lawyers

Book Free Consultation Today!

Don't accept wrongful conviction as your fate

Every conviction deserves expert review for appeal prospects.

Proven Track Record
High Success Rate
Top-Rated Lawyers